JTF (just the facts): Published in 2010 by Aperture (
here). 320 pages, with 162 color and black and white images by 11 different photographers. Includes a
foreword by
Lothar Schirmer, an essay by Stefan
Gronert, and summary biographies, exhibition lists and bibliographies for each of the artists. The German version of the book is being published by Schirmer/Mosel (
here). (Cover shot at right, via Amazon.)
The photographers included/discussed are:
Bernd &
Hilla BecherLaurenz BergesElger EsserAndreas
GurskyCandida
HöferAxel
HütteSimone
NiewegThomas Ruff
Jörg SasseThomas
StruthPetra
WunderlichComments/Context: The
Düsseldorf school of photography is probably the largest topic in contemporary photography that has yet to receive the kind of in-depth scholarly treatment we would expect for such an important and influential artistic movement. While I'm sure there have been quite a few masters and
Ph.D. theses that have been written about the
Bechers and their students, until the publication of this book, there have been effectively no survey style volumes brought to market with the broader public in mind. Given the many monographs and exhibition catalogues that have been written about these photographers individually, the gathering of a representative sample of the various artists' work is the lesser of the challenges here; the real test falls to the essay and how coherently and
insightfully it ties together what heretofore have been generally separate but parallel narratives. We have all been searching for someone to help connect the dots and fill in the gaps; I'm happy to report that this book is certainly a good start.
One important semantic definition is required before we get to the analysis: what is it we mean by the term the "school"? In general, I think there are two possible answers as applied to artistic movements: the narrow - the education derived from a specific set of teachings/
learnings (i.e. the how/what of the curriculum at the
Düsseldorf Kunstakademie or the Yale School of Art and how it was absorbed by specific students), and the broad - the larger geographic and temporal phenomenon (i.e.
Düsseldorf or Helsinki as the umbrella term for a common style of working).
This volume (and its keystone essay) has chosen to focus on the
Düsseldorf school in the broad sense, looking for the larger commonalities seen in its most successful and best known adherents. It lays at the feet of the
Bechers the "emancipation of photography": the critical artistic mindset that photography was fully equal to painting, the results of which are embodied in the downstream success of the students who wholeheartedly embraced this unorthodox-at-the-time concept. It also implies an amorphous teaching by osmosis approach, where the
Bechers were effectively leading by example: off doing their own highly stringent and objective documentary work, using the series and typology as modes for working and comparison, all underneath a rigid conceptual framework, with the students watching and absorbing some or all of what they saw as they saw fit. The narrative is thus one of commonality rather than causation: the students all started from a generally similar location; as they grew and matured as artists and selectively incorporated the
Bechers' teachings over time, they went off in different but often parallel directions.
While there are some
anecdotal comparisons and back and forth between the artists, in general, the book follows each photographer down his or her own particular evolutionary path, often starting prior to their involvement with the
Bechers, and running to the present, now decades after the teacher/student relationship has ended. Each photographer gets a short biographical analysis, often through the lens of the
Düsseldorf similarities. We see some exploring the limits of conceptual ideas (Ruff,
Hütte,
Esser,
Struth,
Sasse), while others have consistently worked in subject matter based series (
Höfer,
Wunderlich,
Nieweg,
Struth); over time, many have experimented with the use of large formats and prints (
Höfer,
Hütte,
Nieweg,
Struth,
Berges, Ruff,
Esser,
Gursky). The challenge here is that most of these artists have worked through a handful of different projects over their careers to date, moving back and forth between working styles and approaches - the
Düsseldorf narrative is therefore circular and cyclical rather than strictly linear, the
Bechers' influence waxing and waning as the artists continually evolve and reinvent themselves.
As such, the story of the
Düsseldorf school is not nearly as neat and tidy as one might expect from the rigid Germans; the
Bechers put down some foundation concepts, but their students have long since moved beyond those initial ideas. Perhaps it is the mark of great teachers that they imparted their wisdom and experience about successful methods for discovering one's artistic voice through photography, without imposing their own specific vision too strongly.
While this book provides the satisfying summary and overview I have outlined, I found myself still wishing for more specifics; perhaps the next scholarly book on the
Düsseldorf school needs to limit its scope to the period when the photographers were actually studying with the
Bechers, and needs to cover in more detail how the curriculum was embodied in the early pictures. I'd also like to see more work from a broader range of the students (not just the "winners") to see how the teachings got applied in different ways. Similarly, I think some commentary from the artists themselves on what they took away from the
Becher experience would be enlightening. Clearly, all of these photographers have long since moved beyond their early education, but I for one would be interested to hear what if anything they still find of value.
Overall, this book fills a gaping hole in the history of photography. It provides a well-selected sampler of the work of the best known members of the
Düsseldorf school and offers a readable explanation of how it all fits together. While I have an insatiable appetite for more on this group of photographers, this volume certainly delivers a solid and thoughtful introduction to one of the most important movements in contemporary photography.
Collector’s POV: In many ways, there isn't much "new" information to be found in this book on the best known photographers in the group. It was therefore the sections on Petra
Wunderlich, Simone
Nieweg,
Jörg Sasse, and
Laurenz Berges that were the eye openers for me, in terms of exposing me more fully to some of the other students who are a little further out of spotlight. I also think the essay was helpful in clarifying my rudimentary understanding of the evolution of both Axel
Hütte and
Elger Esser, neither of which I have felt particularly comfortable with in the past.
Transit Hub:- Review: Conscientious (here)
Van Ham wraps up the Spring season in Germany later this week in Cologne with a various owner Photographs sale with a broad base of lower priced German/European material. Overall, there are a total of 216 lots on offer in this sale, with a Total High Estimate of €566800.
The top lot by High estimate is tied between two lots: lot 1111, Christian Boltanski, Jewish School, Große Hamburger Straße, Berlin, 1939, 1993 (image at right, middle, via Van Ham) and lot 1221, Candida Höfer, Teatro Colon, Buenos Aires, 2006 (image at right, top, via Van Ham), both estimated at €50000-60000.
Other lots of interest include lot 1228, Li Wei, Freedegree Over 25th Story, 2004, estimated at €5000-6000 (image at right, bottom, via Van Ham).
